I recently re-read an
article critiquing many of the large scale federal initiatives for youth. The authors, Jon Baron of the
Coalition for Evidence-Based Practices and Isabel Sawhill a Senior Fellow at the
Brookings Institute, indicate that of the ten major federal programs subject to random assignment evaluations, the gold standard, only one was proven to work. A pretty bleak assessment.
The author's do point to examples of programs that have been shown to work. Among the programs with positive outcomes are the
Carrera Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention Program;
LifeSkills training for middle schools; and
Multidimensional Treatment Foster Care.
So, two question for all of us who are working now to make a difference for youth: 1) Is your program or strategy evidence-based? 2) Is there room for innovation in this brave new world of "best practices"?